Before using this page, please read the reasons for its existence on Wikipedia:Cleanup process.
|
- keep - fine - nonsense - unimproved - insufficient - meta - asdfjkl - stubified - expand - nonexistent - obscure - idiosyncratic - advert - selfpromotion - ungrammatic - ????? - silly - joke - repeat - link - chatty - rant - POV - NPOV - copyvio - brilliant - obscenity - blog - vanity page- ... |
- Please note that most comments on this page are first impressions, not considered analyses of any one article. Thinking deeply before listing an article here is not actually discouraged, but it is definitely not a requirement either.
- Limit your comments to a few words only; verbose comments will be edited for brevity!
- New entries go at top.
- Begin your comment with a "-" to separate it from the previous comment, but:
- If you have made a change to the page in question or are reporting a change made to the page, Use a "+" instead to indicate a change (e.g. "+ fixed the first paragraph", "+ deleted" or "+ stubbified")
- The comment "delete" or "VFD" is a vote to move this page to Wikipedia:Votes for deletion, not to delete it immediately. It is considerate to enclose such listings within ''' emphasis.
- If you think that the article meets the criteria for speedy deletion, then write "delete immediately".
- Edit conflicts on Cleanup can be mitigated by copying your own text before you submit it, so you can paste and repost it quickly.
NEW
AIDS reappraisal - needs smoothing, structure
Edie Bukewihge - advert
Deep Ecology (company) - full wikify needed; first person POV
Kenneth O'Keefe - also listed on VFD - needs serious pruning
Zeitun - unwikified, no intro -vfd? could be copyvio but claims to be written by the author
Cathy Jones - merge with This Hour Has 22 Minutes
26th century - sub-stub, premature - VFD?
She-Ra - cartoon character, merge + Expanded (Smerdis of Tlön)
Porto Velho - stub, edit, format, expand, merge
Geolibertarian - sub-stub, 242 Google hits, expand, merge, delete,
Diary of an Ordinary Woman - 121 Google hits, format, edit, delete, merge
Pre-industrial - fragment, format, edit, delete, merge
Withdrawal method - merge with Birth control
Malacology - dictionary entry, expand or merge with Mollusc
Home Depot - sub-stub, dubious value
Polish-Soviet war - format, edit, delete, merge
Ski school - detail, format etc
Pheidole - prob needs deleting
either - barely better than dictionary entry
Articles by 202.154.157.117 - substub, need wikification or deletion. andy 09:10, 30 Oct 2003 (UTC)
Monday Report - reads like a press release Secretlondon
Trichloromethyl chloroformate and Chloromethyl chloroformate- layout, detail etc. I corrected spelling Secretlondon 21:35, Oct 29, 2003 (UTC)
Polish areas annexed by Nazi Germany -layout, detail, fact checking... Secretlondon 21:25, Oct 29, 2003 (UTC) Also Polish areas annexed by Soviet Union and Polish-Soviet war
California Pacific International Exposition- doesn't appear to be copyvio, but needs detail, NPOV etc Secretlondon 21:25, Oct 29, 2003 (UTC)
Careertimes.com.hk - dunno how websites are formated
Independent Commission Against Corruption - no context, not even what country
Oath of the Peach Gardent - insufficient context
Furman_v._Georgia - layout, doesn't explain why important (if it is) Secretlondon
Owen mab Urien - layout, name needs checking ~~
Color perception - sub-stub; fix or delete
The Wuzzles
- stub, needs wiki, rewrite
Reptilian humanoid - fake science? +totally crap science, but when did that make it unwikiworthy? DJ Clayworth common in conspiracy theories cf. antisemetism Secretlondon
King Edward's school - unwikified, needs rewrite +stubbed DJ Clayworth
Domestic free television programme services - Poor name, sub-stub, merge elsewhere? +moved and copyedited. Now at Free television services (Hong Kong) Secretlondon
Sidewinder - needs cleanup, make into disambig page?
Geneon Entertainment (USA) - unwikified, nearly sub-stub
Baltimore Development Corporation - unwikified
Persecution of Muslims - fragment
Phillips artificial neural network law - no Google hits
Kravica - POV and contextless - as contextless as any other city/village page
Things Falling Apart - needs wikification and formatting
Festivals of Plagiarism - ????? - nonsense, source material?: delete immediately. + listed at VFD
Phoenix Television
- advert, needs formatting
NEW
Comparative Historical - makes no sense - VfD + Redirected to Comparative method (Smerdis of Tlön)
Competitions for classical music
- needs some more or needs deleting
Daisho - doesn't make sense - Now redirected to wakizashi.
Subject-object problem - POV nonsense.Smerdis of Tlön
Cheung Man Yee - unwikified. + wikified Secretlondon
Christer Pettersson - stub
Carl Thompson - stub
Cardiac arrhythmias
- needs proper intro merging with cardiac arrhythmia
Carolina Shag - a mess
Proxima Centuri - sub-stub. redirect to the novel it comes from? + this is factual and fine Secretlondon
Cubicle desk - rewrite (contains things like "on a personal note...") + rewrote that section only, rest ok
Creme Anglaise - needs wikifying and stuff + fixed spelling, added links; perhaps someone has a more complete recipe?
Siege of Sarajevo - (insufficient) + vfd Secretlondon
Primitive Lyrics
- (slangy, POV)
Legally separated - (overly specific)
Chisholm Trail District - (unencyclopedic)
Courtisanerie - not really wiktionary, but not quite encyclopaedic either
Pseudo - half dictionary, half nonsense + Reworded; probably still dictionary material. No idea what to do about equations and control theory.
Costate equations - nonsense?
Fresh
Emishi - new contents need to be wikified + wikified, fine
Gennifer Flowers - no biographical info on her; make into article or delete
Faith Fancher - linked to recent deaths, but article has no dates + does now - fine
Tachinid - only has photo with messed up html
Latin names of regions - factual problems
Fresh
Desknote - reads like an advertisment. - anybody have any balancing dirt on Desknote? - outdated. Updated body text, needs more wikification and work, as do the computer types it references.
Virtue (economics) - huh? - would be dictionary definition, if it only made sense
The Peoples of Middle-earth - what? + it's a book in the History of Middle-earth series. If the book is worthy of inclusion, the article should stay or at least be moved to the article about the series (which IS worthy).
Tony Shryane - offtopic - unencyclopaedic, even if not copyvio
Poznan (old article) - duplicate + is redirect now, was created by vandal after Poznan was protected
Objective, Subjective - dictionary
Namibian dollar - unwikified and sub-stub
Fresh
Girl's Not Grey - need wikification and checking + made stub + made redirect to AFI
Archery at the 1988 Summer Olympics - needs factual checking
L. J. Magnus - Can't find any relevant Google hits
Tradeoff - off topic? + expand/tidied, wikified
Free-kick - merge with football somehow
Bobbing for apples - nonsense, not encyclopedic
Fresh
Hillel Slovak - sub-stub - looks OK to me + looks Fine.
Cullen Inquiry - only external links
Mesannepada - sub stub, delete? - work in progress, just maybe?
Tryphaena Cleopatraina - sub stub
Building construction - a mess + fixed a few paragraphs + total rewrite; now OK stub
Fresh
Beefcake - Winad. Needs to be merged with some list of slang somewhere - merge and redir to Glamour photography
Tian Han - most of the text in unintelligible. Maybe a machine translation. - would have to be fixed by someone who knows Tian Han
Josef Duchac, Werner Eggerath, Rudolf Paul, Herrmann Brill, and Werner Bruschke - too concise - have been fixed
Ancient listings
Wikipedia:Cleanup - obscure; incomprehensible; sinister - dont use it then, its a free wiki,戴眩sv - warm, fuzzy, cuddly, cute, and sweet
Eastern Armenian verb table - source info.
Red Rus - should be merged with appropriate article(s), then deleted if the term is not in wide use - no real content, just redirect where appropriate
Norsk Hydro - delete - possibly copyvio, but the text can be rewritten. It's a big Norwegian oil company, and worth a mention. - don't think copyvio, needs article
Black Lake, Louisiana
- unwikified, content only about Bonny & Clyde
Educational behaviorism - (merge with Philosophy of education) - no - should be/has been merged with behaviourism
Hans Asperger - (merge valid content with Asperger's disorder)
Ancient listings
Spider Woman - needs wikification
Dolphin Intelligence - (a lot esoteric nonsense, possible copyvio as partly identical with [1])
Contractarianism - (idiosyncratic?)
Felix Wakefield - (idiosyncratic, probably valid, but unwikified) + (wikified)
Ancient listings
Sniggle - (wiktionary) - maybe WP:VFD?
Subsistence farming - (wiktionary) - perhaps merge somewhere
Example - (wiktionary)
History of Poland -- World War II 1939-1945 - (shoddy outline with little content) - History of Poland already covers this - keep, maybe in progress - no, last major edit was done over a year ago + copied to VFD
Panda Hotel - (advert?) - one of the MANY hotels in Hong Kong, nothing special, would delete - interesting, neutral, wikified. Compare rambot, smaller places - granularity problem, move to "List of Hong Kong hotels
Erotophobia - (idiosyncratic?) - merge with Love-shyness