Before using this page, please read the reasons for its existence on Wikipedia:Cleanup process.
|
- keep - fine - nonsense - unimproved - insufficient - meta - asdfjkl - stubified - expand - nonexistent - obscure - idiosyncratic - advert - selfpromotion - ungrammatic - ????? - silly - joke - repeat - link - chatty - rant - POV - NPOV - copyvio - brilliant - obscenity - blog - vanity page- ... |
- Please note that most comments on this page are first impressions, not considered analyses of any one article. Thinking deeply before listing an article here is not actually discouraged, but it is definitely not a requirement either.
- Limit your comments to a few words only; verbose comments will be edited for brevity!
- New entries go at top.
- Begin your comment with a "-" to separate it from the previous comment, but:
- If you have made a change to the page in question or are reporting a change made to the page, Use a "+" instead to indicate a change (e.g. "+ fixed the first paragraph", "+ deleted" or "+ stubbified")
- The comment "delete" or "VFD" is a vote to move this page to Wikipedia:Votes for deletion, not to delete it immediately. Please list such entries in bold ('''entry''').
- If you think that the article meets the criteria for speedy deletion, then write "delete immediately".
- Edit conflicts on Cleanup can be mitigated by copying your own text before you submit it, so you can paste and repost it quickly.
- For older articles needing a cleanup, see Wikipedia:Pages needing attention, or see current stubs.
JUST IN
Currency bill tracking - currently mostly external links!
David R. Corey - sub-stub, non-famous?
F. Van Wyck Mason - see Talk:F. Van Wyck Mason
Mass media in India- rewrite/ fmt
Stanley Pons - unfinished, merge, delete
Kadesh - stub, merge
A.'.A.'. - sounds like a hoax?
Freedom Summer - needs lots
Belfry -sub-stub that manages not to mention bells. Bmills
Jonestown mass suicide - repeat - the content has been merged to Jonestown. - Card
Posh Spice Takes it Up the Arse and other football chants (e.g. Who ate all the pies) -VfD DJ Clayworth -VfD +have been put on VfD
Lottery machine - not quite sure what this is, but it's not an article and I don't see how it could become one. DavidWBrooks 15:18, 26 Nov 2003 (UTC) +rewritten DJ Clayworth
Roger Boyle - needs wikification
Amiternum - extreme stub. Delete if not improved
Gisèle Lestrange - extreme stub
Fritz Albert Lipmann - sub-stub. Delete if not improved.
Ardysus I, Ardysus II, Alyattes I, Meles, Candaules - sub-stub. Delete if not improved.
Rohirrim, Northmen, Elvish, Cirion, Calenardhon -- stubs, merge with J.R.R. Tolkien
Thomas Jackson - wikify
D.O.A. - stub, delete
Character descriptions for Their Eyes Were Watching God, Chapter-by-chapter summary of Their Eyes Were Watching God - currently only an outline -VfD DJ Clayworth
Abcess Root - subStub. Not a dental term, but a flowering plant. Anthropos
ATV New provide - advertisment. maybe could be decent article, but needs lots of help.
deadAIM - NPOV
ANCEP - orphan. could be a good article, but needs work. Virutally all documentation online is in Norwegian.Anthropos
Liberation movement - not Wikipedia. seglea, press release?
Aquatic respiration - rewording, not wikipedia-style. But since I don't get the point what it's all about, can please someone else do so? + hard to know where to start, maybe better to just delete for now? seglea
Chrysomelidae- needs rewrite. looks like a copyvio but not from anywhere I can find.
Eric Vloeimans -- non-famous?
WTC Temporary Memorial Design Number One - should this even be here?
NEW
Human-Truth Paradox -- nonsense; no reference to theory or its authors anywhere else. Salvageable? +no. VfD. DJ Clayworth +VfD Pete +VfD silsor
EPSP substub, merge
Technocapitalism - advert?
Genus Helix not wikified, not understandable for laymen
Verrottentrolls im Pilzwald is this a joke? - yes; the MP3 from the link was obviously sequenced on desktop. +listed on vfd
Shivini - machine translation - two words in original language + translated, links added
Cambridge United F.C. - fix the chart please +fixed-ish
Terrestrial Kingdom - very POV, delete (maybe someone can salvage it)? +wikified
R. Joe Brandon - wikify, vanity?
Comptroller and Auditor General
Lead (II) sulfate - needs rewriting into whole sentences -VfD DJ Clayworth
Rosin - stubby, accuracy?
Commitment, Cautiousness wiktionary? (see below for Deference)
I-6- anyone speak car?
Thomas Bata - npov
Ford Country Squire - anyone speak car? +stubbed DJ Clayworth
Creole from Spanish or Machaco language - machine translation - VfD, ersatz
Baltic obsolete racial classification - needs NPOV etc
Atharva-Veda - This looks screwed up. Note the random(?) capital letters within words.
Nematics - is this an aggregate state or a mathematical concept? don't understand the article - bit of physical chemistry or suchlike, just needs better introduction
Shaheen Lakhan and Talk:Shaheen Lakhan - delete, rd to user pages
Deference - bizarre +Dependability, Determination Discernment Enthusiasm - in fact a growing number of newly created articles by the same user. In Virtue he has identified 49 'virtues' which he says 'have been developed', but doesn't say where or by whom. I am sceptical. I have heard of 10 commandments, 7 deadly sins, 39 articles, etc, - but not "49 virtues", which seems an arbitrary choice, and could grow and grow as he or anyone sees fit. See also Talk:Virtue on this topic.
Truancy - wiktionary?
Fundamental business concepts - I would like to merge the first 2 paragraphs with the main business page, and delete the rest (including the arbitrary list of accounting concepts). What does everybody think? mydogategodshat
Solenopsis,Solenopsis invicta unwikified and duplicates DJ Clayworth
Casasimarro, Cuenca - stub, expand, merge, delete +reworded +slightly expanded
Chris Faust vanity?
3-D not nonsense, but very close, delete or replace with something better?
NEWISH
Cog about a TV commercial, delete? -Delete. Page here should be about the ship type, not about some commercial.
Kunikida Doppo short on info
Roman architecture - miserable stub, a year old, important subject
Fishbait - wiktionary
South Park, Houston - ugh.
Prussia and linked pages - someone split the article up, but the result seems very messy + ugh, could someone just restore what used to be there, prussia article know a fragmented mess
Peripheral nervous system - needs reformatting.
John Russell, 4th Duke of Bedford - needs organization, sectioning
Fischer Black - bring this up to stub status
Iridology and Iris (anatomy) - recently flooded with POV. Please help make it NPOV
Penn Masala - needs wikification, checking +wikiification
American Desi - needs wikify, explanation of what it is +wikification
Soyuz TMA-3 needs outcome + past tense; also "last/ next mission" box, per Soyuz TMA-2. Andy Mabbett
Cap Arcona - inadequate ttrasnlation? Andy Mabbett
Elvin Jones - npov
ELSBETT - needs HELP
Street fighting - npov, rant - The Anome
Competitive Feasting and the Evolution of Power in Mesoamerica - mediocre undergrad essay. If someone thinks it worth while to make this into a wikipedia article, go for it, otherwise I'm listing it on Vfd -- Infrogmation
Politics of Afghanistan - needs wikification, major edit
Afghan Constitution Commission - needs wikification, major edits
Michal Arkusz - selfpromotion, VfD
- See also Sanacja, Jozef Arkusz, Naczelnik and other edits by User:68.98.126.213. Andy Mabbett
Bromley, Bromley, London, England - sub-stub, odd title
- redirected to Bromley, Bromley. Andy Mabbett +sorted
Malcolm McLaren - very stubby.
Kahan Summation Algorithm - very stubby. What's this algorithm doing?
Superior Dome - bullet list only +sorted
2003 in Live action series substub, misspelled.
Alps and the many articles that came along with from EB. -- wikification, updating, etc.
Sampon and perhaps the related page Manpon. Sampon is useless. Manpon is, at best, a definition. Rholton + redirected "sampon" to "manpon", both could probably be deleted
Papa John's Pizza - advert, rewrite, npov, VfD + doesn't seem that bad to me, a little biased
List of legends and myths - a motley, incomplete, systemless collection
Totemism - copyedit
Pagan Activism - just 3 external links +gone to VfD DJ Clayworth
Energies of God - bizarre -- delete, evangelistic, not an article on the subject - keep, very important concept in Eastern Orthodox theology. Needs expansion for non-EO reader and NPOV. I've expanded and worked on NPOV. It's now more informational and less strange and polemic Dogface
Pentamedia - verify. build.
Jojutsu - is this related to jiu jitsu? - doubt it
Forty-five (card game) - needs standardization + copyedits, may still need work
Supporting character contentless, delete
John Otto -substub
Fox Box - jargony, advertising
Spades (game)- wikification etc - spades exists, merge
Mask of Dimitrios - context, wikify
Lew Wallace - needs fleshing out
Jerry Lucas - WIKIFY + wikified & copyedited, could use NPOV check
Porto Velho - tiny stub, needs some content & context.
Juvenile delinquency - less than a stub, just some "see also"s
Joseph Alessi - npov
Fissures - sub stub -VfD DJ Clayworth
Vanity of Duluoz - wikification, doesn't seem to be copyvio + perhaps a few minor factual issues as well? MK
Adam_Busby - npov
Debye model - needs lots
East Bay Ray - please doll it up
OLDISH
Proust Questionaire -source text
Robert Tannahill - unwikified, smells of copyvio +can't find a copyvio unless out of a book + prob. an old, old book, nobody uses real paragraphs anymore
Angel of death - unwikified, pov, first person - looks like a possible copyright violation, references to being an introduction from "this book" MK - Rename Death (fictional character) to something like Death (personification) and move, if not copyright? (Smerdis of Tlön) - On second thought, at least the top of this page is copyvio; Leilah Wendell cited as author. (Smerdis of Tlön)
Software engineering - 'Criticisms' section is not encyclopedically written
Software license - has fixme notes
Database log - has fixme, todo notes
ROM BASIC programming language - no BASIC dialect, suggest covering in main BASIC article instead. Wernher - Delete, all info is already in main BASIC article and this orphan is not a term people will look up. Tempshill +redirect
Street furniture - less than a sentence - improved, but still a tiny stub
Sensor Networks - was VfD but 66% voted keep
Naniwa-ku, Oosaka - pov, unwikified, title wrong
Foreign relations of Serbia and Montenegro - someone, second - what does that comment mean? - I've cleaned up the page, someone else, please second it and move it off this list if it is okay.
Foreign relations of Bulgaria - fmt, links + links and some fmting
Foreign relations of Slovenia - fmt, links
ITU prefix - fmt, links
Linux User Group - links
Medical marijuana - fmt, links
Dalgety Bay - needs a 'lil research to make better
Ume - Probably new user.
Quincy Carter (a football player) - stub
Sima Yi - needs lots
Monday Report - pov and in the future + on VfD
Arlington City and County, Virginia - There is no city named Arlington in Virginia; Arlington is a county, a post office, and a census-designated place, but not a city. I moved the information to its proper place at Arlington County, Virginia. - BRG
Our Lady of La Salette and Secret of La Salette - Merge? -- Tualha
- Merge and include text/links from La Salette. olivier 09:29, 21 Nov 2003 (UTC)
Martin Fox - vanity?
Class War - I've moved a big chunk of POV text to the talk page for wiki-ing and NPOV editing. quercus robur 11:56, 17 Nov 2003 (UTC)
HTML tag - needs rewrite to cover deprecated tags, valid HTML, good practice, etc. - Should go to Wikipedia:Pages needing attention
Blowing Rock - a mass of info needs love - now stubbish w/o town info ; Cleanup now more needed for Blowing Rock, North Carolina
Wikipedia:Chemical ASCII-art useless - Agreed, delete immediately. Tualha + I believe it was brought up last month on Vfd, and the decision was to keep. - still should be deleted, unimprovable & useless, FYI I listed on vfd last month Maximus Rex
Bass fishing - A mess
Time-based currency - See talk page. POV issues. Was previously on VfD.
KiAi - odd case in title, dictionary stub (Smerdis of Tlön)
Halogenoalkane - expand, possibly move to "Haloalkane". Zack
Postcolonial theory & Postcolonial literature - it ain't nothin' yet
John Madden Football - Come on, POV. Omnipotent Q + worked on the spelling (one small step) MK + toned down the POV, wikified a bit, needs more work but now IMO acceptable -Morven
Open source record label - POV
Ernest Saunders- Trial only. What else?
Mount Arith - delete, substub + just barely at stub status now, can use more info
Constructal theory - looks like some kook pushing their theory Morwen
Ilium (band) - pov
History of Coins either needs expansion or merging?
Bimorphism - sub stub, needs explanation - needs example, article could be usefull with work
CPRE - wikification
Joseph Buford Cox - checking, wiki etc
Frode - some info, needs checking, editing if it can be salvaged
Riesenburg sub-stub, incomplete sentences (need info to complete)
Mygdon of Bebryces - The songs of yore say little about him; what is, is there. (Smerdis of Tlön)
Radiation of sound - needs wikification, restructuring, maybe merge with sound
The First 20 Million Is Always The Hardest - too long, disorganized. Tualha
Bambuco - translated with altavista, which didn't do a very good job
Marvin Olasky stub, unimportant?
Chris Perez - stub
Lettrisme -substub +more detail - Needs at least a short introduction explaining what Lettrisme is
Kuquenan falls - detail, context. sub stub
The Village - source text
Nicholas Knatchbull - 14 year old, only famous for his ancestry and his death
Edwin F. Uhl 19th cent. text listing person as if still alive
The testing of LSD by the U.S. Army
Abington School District v. Schempp POV, unwikified
Wüstite - needs sentences
Nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide - unwikified text is about ATP/ADP, not about the topic of the article - merge into Adenosine triphosphate if anything useful, then delete
James Pennington - needs wikifying, stubbifying etc
Secondary cell - insufficient, expand, no idea what it's about + added context
Lab color space - needs explanation of some variables
August-Wilhelm Scheer - Univ. Prof. Dr. Dr. h.c. mult. August-Wilhelm Scheer?
Pennsylvania library system - puff piece, yawn - ~
Onix - Contexts/specialized "pokemon" phrases unclear
Photoemission - needs intro -should probably be merged into photoelectric effect
OLD
Post-colonialism in literature - just 2 sources
ROSS - advert+deleteAnthropos 15:09, 24 Nov 2003 (UTC)
PSOLA sub stub theresa knott-immediate deletion DJ Clayworth - Why? It's not hurting anyone.
Laura Schlessinger - 1001 external links +removed links; now just very biasedDJ Clayworth - Hard to write article about controversial figure and leave out the controversies, that's what makes subject interesting. Moved links to end. Madhaus 08:13, 20 Nov 2003 (UTC) Rapidly turning into a revision war, we need a neutral party, quick. Madhaus 10:18, 20 Nov 2003 (UTC)
Light Upon Light - what is it? -vfd DJ Clayworth - the author was the same person who inserted a link to that site into Islam - advert. VFD. silsor 00:54, Nov 18, 2003 (UTC) +put it on VfD
Nasheed - expand?
Carlists seems POV
FM radio - just US atm. Secretlondon 15:31, Nov 11, 2003 (UTC)
Economic value added - stubby - only a definition at this stage, but the formula looks right - mydogategodshat 06:58, 14 Nov 2003 (UTC) + Made changes to definition,linked important concepts, and added some text. mydogategodshat 07:31, 14 Nov 2003 (UTC)
Aircraft Carrier Minas Gerais - needs more context setting and a decent intro
Belonging - questionable... maybe.
Ahoah - could evolve into something, currently dictionary.
Golden Age of Latin Literature - seems incomplete + expanded, still needs a lot of work (Smerdis of Tlön)
Paul Truong - needs decoding
Group 28 project - renaming, wikification etc
Rory Barnes - vanity page? (written by R Barnes)
Interstate Bakeries Corporation
Superfund Emergency Response - merge with Superfund Site
Glengormley unwikified mess w/o sentences
Victoria Harbor - no wiki
Tourist Attractions in Delhi - previously on VfD
Direct Marketing Association only a quote
Computer lab - wiktionary
Clarice Lispector - one sentence.
Sensor Networks - less-than-stub.
List of land-grant universities - merge with Land-grant university +change to redirect/no unique content Pmineault
Article Seven (United States Constitution) - source text, move to ps?
Geneva Conference - primary source material
Tampon Needs much more information
SIOR. Was on VfD. Needs npov rewrite.
Protest of Zofia Kossak-Szczucka - sourcetext, rewrite and copy to ps: + rewritten as stub, + source moved to ps, maybe merge with Zofia Kossak-Szczucka.
ANCIENT LISTINGS
Metroid II: Return of Samus - looks like sci-fi short stories, but linked to video game Samus Aran, so possibly some valid content if cleaned up? If not, delete
Integration testing - merge into Software engineering
Generalfeldmarschall - stub, format, expand, merge
Bulawayo - stub, expand, merge
Reductibility - idiosyncratic, merge? (see MCS) - ditto Lexor
Fluency - - idiosyncratic, merge? (see MCS) - ditto Lexor + stub about languages; no clue about the rest Smerdis of Tlön