Wikipedia:Mediation Cabal/Cases/2005-12-26 Stuyvesant High School

Request for cabal mediation

Initial request

Request made by: BenjaminTsai 20:44, 26 December 2005 (UTC)[reply]

Where is the issue taking place?: Question of whether the edits by Bobbydoop, 24.239.149.9 and other anonymous IP are biased or not. The issues being disputed is outlined here under NPOV dispute section.

Who's involved?: Bobbydoop, 24.239.149.9 and other anonymous IP against other contributors of the article.

What's going on?: Bobbydoop, 24.239.149.9 and other anonymous IP insists on edits to the page which many other contributors of the article feel is biased against Stuyvesant High School. They also refuse to conform to Wikipedia style guideline. Recently they have acted particularly controversial with comments like: "the Stuyvesant article is too long according to wikipedia. a large scale deletion of information may be in order."

The issues that remains unresolved are the inclusion of the words "thus far" in admission requirement, the placement of the "See also" links at the introductory section, and allegations of existing asbestos danger today at the school campus.

What would you like to change about that?: Restore NPOV through consensus instead of revert wars.

If you'd prefer we work discreetly, how can we reach you?: E-mail.

Comments by others

Mediator response

Notes

see Talk:Stuyvesant_High_School#Mediation

There is no apparent need for mediation, only some ongoing minor disagreements about wording. Case closed. --Fasten