Wikipedia:Cleanup
Before using this page, please read the reasons for its existence on Wikipedia:Cleanup process.
|
- keep - fine - nonsense - unimproved - insufficient - meta - asdfjkl - stubified - expand - nonexistent - obscure - idiosyncratic - advert - selfpromotion - ungrammatic - ????? - silly - joke - repeat - link - chatty - rant - POV - NPOV - copyvio - brilliant - obscenity - blog - vanity page- ... |
- Please note that most comments on this page are first impressions, not considered analyses of any one article. Thinking deeply before listing an article here is not actually discouraged, but it is definitely not a requirement either.
- Limit your comments to a few words only; verbose comments will be edited for brevity!
- New entries go at top.
- Begin your comment with a "-" to separate it from the previous comment, but:
- If you have made a change to the page in question or are reporting a change made to the page, Use a "+" instead to indicate a change (e.g. "+ fixed the first paragraph", "+ deleted" or "+ stubbified")
- The comment "delete" or "VFD" is a vote to move this page to Wikipedia:Votes for deletion, not to delete it immediately. It would be helpful to list such entries in bold (''' ''').
- If you think that the article meets the criteria for speedy deletion, then write "delete immediately".
- Edit conflicts on Cleanup can be mitigated by copying your own text before you submit it, so you can paste and repost it quickly.
JUST IN
Open source record label - POV
Automatic mathematics - does this even exist?
Ernest Saunders- Trial only. What else?
Ben Linder - far from NPOV - POV + POV = NPOV
Alternate words for British - whimsical, some UKian should review this
Apple Crisp - Is wikipedia a recipe box?
Mount Arith - delete, substub
Constructal theory - looks like some kook pushing their theory Morwen
Supply side economics, Supply-side economics should merge
Ilium (band) - pov
Kepa Te Rangihiwinui stakato other-encyclopedias-are-paper style. Expand into sentences
Sam Brownback substub
History of Coins either needs expansion or merging?
Bimorphism - sub stub, needs explaination
CPRE - wikification
Joseph Buford Cox - checking, wiki etc
Frode - some info, needs checking, editing if it can be salvaged
Groundhog - insufficient, expand
- give me a bit of time and I'll fix it. there's plenty that could be said - seglea
Alticor - delete, contents "Hi my name is billy bob" + fixed, still stubby
Riesenburg sub-stub, incomplete sentences (need info to complete)
Radiation of sound - needs wikification, restructuring, maybe merge with sound
The First 20 Million Is Always The Hardest - too long, disorganized. Tualha
Bambuco - translated with altavista, which didn't do a very good job
Marvin Olasky stub, unimportant?
Chris Perez - stub
Lettrisme -substub
Kuquenan falls - detail, context. sub stub
The Village - source text
Youth hostel - dictionary definition + now has a short history
Nicholas Knatchbull - 14 year old, only famous for his ancestry and his death
Hispalinux - wikification etc + converted babelfish autotranslation to valid stub
Edwin F. Uhl 19th cent. text listing person as if still alive
Ancalagon + given it context and stub alert, but still quite short
The testing of LSD by the U.S. Army
Abington School District v. Schempp POV, unwikified
Wüstite - needs sentences
Nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide - unwikified text is about ATP/ADP, not about the topic of the article - merge into Adenosine triphosphate if anything useful, then delete
James Pennington - needs wikifying, stubbifying etc
Ibrahim Petrovich Gannibal - needs major work to make it english
- Did a heavy edit. MK
Danny Wallace - advert
Secondary cell - insufficient, expand, no idea what it's about + added context
Lab color space - needs explanation of some variables
John Walsh - less sentimental + rm pov sentiment
August-Wilhelm Scheer - Univ. Prof. Dr. Dr. h.c. mult. August-Wilhelm Scheer?
Pennsylvania library system - puff piece, yawn - ~
Barbary pirates - childish
Photoemission - needs intro -should probably be merged into photoelectric effect
Post-colonialism in literature - just 2 sources
ROSS - advert
Fort Niagara - childish sub-stub +stubbed DJ Clayworth
PSOLA sub stub theresa knott-immediate deletion DJ Clayworth - Why? It's not hurting anyone.
Laura Schlessinger - 1001 external links +removed links; now just very biasedDJ Clayworth
VERY NEW
Light Upon Light - what is it? -vfd DJ Clayworth
Nasheed - expand?
Carlists seems POV
University of Mainz not about the university! - VfD/copyvio
FM radio - just US atm. Secretlondon 15:31, Nov 11, 2003 (UTC)
Economic value added - stubby - only a definition at this stage, but the formula looks right - mydogategodshat 06:58, 14 Nov 2003 (UTC) + Made changes to definition,linked important concepts, and added some text. mydogategodshat 07:31, 14 Nov 2003 (UTC)
Aircraft Carrier Minas Gerais - needs more context setting and a decent intro
Milky Way candy bar - this stub needs love + gave it some sugar
The Early Show - nothing here -vfd DJ Clayworth
- added some content MK
Belonging - questionable... maybe.
Ahoah - could evolve into something, currently dictionary.
Golden Age of Latin Literature - seems incomplete + expanded, still needs a lot of work (Smerdis of Tlön)
Paul Truong - needs decoding
Emil Leon Post, Witold Hurewicz - just external links . (Keep, major people. [Charles Matthews].)
DG Bank building - no info that isn't in the architect's page
Group 28 project - renaming, wikification etc
Robinson projection - doesn't say what it is + fixed, made stub
Rory Barnes - vanity page? (written by R Barnes)
NEW
Interstate Bakeries Corporation
Superfund Emergency Response - merge with Superfund Site
Victoria Harbor - no wiki
Genesis 3 just a picture (Picture could simply be put inline on the Majesco page, delete Genesis 3 and call it case closed - 'Genesis 3' isn't even linked there) - picture would cause horizontal scrollbar/used redirect instead --Pmineault
Tourist Attractions in Delhi - previously on VfD
Bahai International Community -says nothing -only a link
Sleep Is for Sissies - could even be deleted, imo
Direct Marketing Association only a quote
Computer lab - wiktionary
Clarice Lispector - one sentence.
Bugging devices in EU headquarters - can't stand alone
Sensor Networks - less-than-stub.
Ben Hogan - npov, wikification.
- added an introduction and wikified MK
Saul Lieberman - unwikified
NEWISH
George C. Day - unwikified ungramatic ramble +cleanup attempt by Secretlondon
Mark Hoffman - npov
List of land-grant universities - merge with Land-grant university +change to redirect/no unique content Pmineault
Article Seven (United States Constitution) - source text, move to ps?
Moise Tshombe - unwikified; needs check for copy viol
Geneva Conference - primary source material
Firearm Info Template - probably should be moved to somewhere, but where? +moved to Wikipedia: namespace (kept redirect)
Battle of Baghdad and Battle of Baghdad (1942) - could find no confirmation and this user has submitted more 'probably false' pages. Can anyone check this one actually exists? If so, remove from this page. If not, immediately delete. -moved to vfd --Pmineault 04:09, 13 Nov 2003 (UTC)
Hot Tasty Hot Sauce recipe DJ Clayworth
Choleric - wiktionary +required as referred to by the four humours. DJ Clayworth -being linked does not mean required. However, this one seems ok.
Watermedia painting - just a couple of headers and links
Tampon Needs much more information
SOMEWHAT OLDER
Jorgen Ingmann - nowiki, some pov.
Aimaq - nowiki, weirdness. + Seems to make some sense; capitals & links added Smerdis of Tlön
Skull and Bones - conspiracy theory mingled with encyclopedic material.
SIOR. Was on VfD. Needs npov rewrite.
Software copy protection. Needs fixing. See talk page.
Protest of Zofia Kossak-Szczucka - sourcetext, rewrite and copy to ps: + rewritten as stub, + source moved to ps, maybe merge with Zofia Kossak-Szczucka.
Eduardo Mata - unwikified runon
Vignette - one sentence only -delete DJ Clayworth
OXO Tower - the slang meaning is way to dominant +slang meaning now gone -needs expnading theresa knott
XEW - need wikification and translation
Marvin Camras - stub, lots of potential, rewrite, expand
Getting air - poor unwikified stub - improve, redirect, or delete - Good Wiktionary candidate
Steve Austin - needs fact checking
Mohammed Rafi - needs npoving
Hurlante Nova - non-famous - can't verify
Metroid II: Return of Samus - looks like sci-fi short stories, but linked to video game Samus Aran, so possibly some valid content if cleaned up? If not, delete
OLDISH
Integration testing - merge into Software engineering
Generalfeldmarschall - stub, format, expand, merge
Bulawayo - stub, expand, merge
Turkish Armenia - substub, rewrite, format, expand, merge
Know-how - idiosyncratic, merge? (see MCS) - most of the pages below were written by Dessimoz, and all are bit dictionary defn/idiosync, should merg with something, but not sure what Lexor
Reductibility - idiosyncratic, merge? (see MCS) - ditto Lexor
Fluency - - idiosyncratic, merge? (see MCS) - ditto Lexor + stub about languages; no clue about the rest Smerdis of Tlön
Expertise - - idiosyncratic merge? (see MCS) - ditto Lexor
Simplicity - - idiosyncratic merge? (see MCS) - ditto Lexor
CAcert - context, NPOV etc
Nasalized language - Wiktionary?
Quick Reference Handbook - stub, fmt, merge + fmted - still very poor, what is its use? - sub-stub
Rare mode - rewrite
Brian Greene - many Google hits, stub, expand + slightly expanded. I propose moving to Wikipedia:Pages needing attention
Alexander Shirvanzade - stub, 24 Google hits, POV
The Church of Christ - stub, format, context - npov? - clearly pov, but repairable
Richard Nash Gould - 179 Google hits, vanity, delete
Thietmar - stub, expand, merge. Needs to be checked for NPOV as on german-polish issues. + slightly expanded, but NPOV-check is still necessary
Lubus - stub, little more than redirect +merged and redirected, put on Redirects with possibilities
AIDS reappraisal - needs smoothing, structure...this is degenerating into an edit war, which is why the appear was made here by both parties.
OLD
Edie Bukewihge - now on VFD
Zeitun - unwikified, no intro - vfd? could be copyvio but claims to be written by the author + intro'd - no copyvio. Wikify and shorten.
Cathy Jones - merge with This Hour Has 22 Minutes
26th century - sub-stub, premature - VFD? - delete
Porto Velho - stub, edit, format, expand, merge
Geolibertarian - sub-stub, 242 Google hits, expand, merge, delete,
Diary of an Ordinary Woman - 121 Google hits, format, edit, delete, merge
Pre-industrial - fragment, format, edit, delete, merge
Ski school - detail, format etc
Monday Report - reads like a press release Secretlondon
Trichloromethyl chloroformate and Chloromethyl chloroformate- layout, detail etc. I corrected spelling Secretlondon 21:35, Oct 29, 2003 (UTC)
Polish areas annexed by Nazi Germany -layout, detail, fact checking... Secretlondon 21:25, Oct 29, 2003 (UTC) Also Polish areas annexed by Soviet Union and Polish-Soviet war
California Pacific International Exposition- doesn't appear to be copyvio, but needs detail, NPOV etc Secretlondon 21:25, Oct 29, 2003 (UTC)
Careertimes.com.hk
- poor format, about website, improve or delete
Independent Commission Against Corruption - no context, not even what country
Furman_v._Georgia - layout, doesn't explain why important (if it is) Secretlondon
Owen mab Urien - layout, name needs checking ~~
Color perception - sub-stub; fix or delete, no longer a sub stub but needs merging with colour vision; now fixed, please review
- one or two near-errors in this, and there is much more that could be said - I'll put it on my list - seglea
Domestic free television programme services
- Poor name, sub-stub, merge elsewhere? +moved and copyedited. Now at Free television services (Hong Kong) Secretlondon
VERY OLD
Sidewinder - needs cleanup, make into disambig page?
Geneon Entertainment (USA) - unwikified, nearly sub-stub + listed at VFD/copyvio
Persecution of Muslims - fragment + 14 Nov: Suggested moving to Muslim in talk page. Tualha
Kravica - POV and contextless - as contextless as any other city/village page
Things Falling Apart - needs wikification and formatting
Festivals of Plagiarism - ????? - nonsense, source material?: delete immediately. + listed at VFD
Phoenix Television - advert, needs formatting
Competitions for classical music - needs some more or needs deleting + Moved to List of classical music competitions, listed on Pages needing attention Tualha
Subject-object problem
- POV nonsense. Smerdis of Tlön - Tried to add background, other eyes needed. Smerdis of Tlön - core ideas are correct, but missing important elements (like Kantian categories and Aristolelian universals) and goes on tangents that are only superficially related to the subject. mydogategodshat 00:47, 15 Nov 2003 (UTC)
Christer Pettersson - stub + 14 Nov: no longer stub, but still disgustingly amateurish and biased - Tualha
Carl Thompson - stub
ANCIENT LISTINGS
Carolina Shag - a mess
Creme Anglaise - needs wikifying and stuff + fixed spelling, added links; perhaps someone has a more complete recipe?
Siege of Sarajevo - (insufficient) + vfd Secretlondon I had a crack at a start, but it needs much more work.2toise 13:25, 8 Nov 2003 (UTC)
Primitive Lyrics - (slangy, POV)
Chisholm Trail District - (unencyclopedic)
Courtisanerie - not really wiktionary, but not quite encyclopaedic either
Pseudo - half dictionary, half nonsense + Reworded; probably still dictionary material. No idea what to do about equations and control theory.
Costate equations - nonsense? - keep, not nonsense, anyway [[Charles Matthews]
Latin names of regions - factual problems
Desknote - reads like an advertisment. - anybody have any balancing dirt on Desknote? - outdated. Updated body text, needs more wikification and work, as do the computer types it references. - no need to keep it here; move to Pages needing Attention
Eastern Armenian verb table - source info. - keep
Hans Asperger - (merge valid content with Asperger's disorder)
Dolphin Intelligence - (a lot esoteric nonsense, possible copyvio as partly identical with [1])
Subsistence farming - linked to Agriculture - could be expanded - keep