Jump to content

Wikipedia:Requests for arbitration/Irismeister 2/Evidence

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
This is an old revision of this page, as edited by Mr-Natural-Health (talk | contribs) at 04:04, 31 May 2004 (Response of One Limited Supporter). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

The chief complaints logged appear to be:


This page can only be edited by arbitrators and people who were directly involved in the cited disputes.

If you are not a complainant, an accused party, or a person who supported the view of the accused party in the cited complaint, then please direct your comments to the talk page.

Relevant article disputes

Only the complainants can edit this area


Responses by the accused/supporters

Only the accused party and supporters can edit this area

Response of One Limited Supporter

This is User:Mr-Natural-Health whose name has some how gotten dragged into this dispute in the following Statement by affected party as well as comments that were made by User:Fred Bauder.

Emergency, Mayday, Wiki Wiki
Mayday! The WikiRepublic is in danger! Wikipolice make their coup d'êtat! Please add your voice and come help John here wiki wiki. He is subject not only of personal attacks, this he is getting used to, but to a seven-months full blown campaign of character assasination - by SYSOPS. Look what they say here ! If you stand by your principles, sysops, and editors, it's time to act now. Thank you ! - Yours, - irismeister 17:25, 2004 May 19 (UTC)

This comment by irismeister was written in plain English. It was irismeister's way of coming to my assistance. And, was referring to Wikipedia:Requests for comment/Theresa Knott which was and still is explained in more detail on my talk page. In fact, I believe that I actually used this comment by irismeister as one of the required attempts of resolving my dispute with Theresa Knott on a talk page. Thanks in part to this effort of irismeister Wikipedia:Requests for comment/Theresa Knott was certified within the 48 time limit.

Therefore, this quote of irismeister cannot be used as part of the Statement by affected party since it was a totally proper statement written in plain English.

Next, both irismeister and I are participants of the Wikiproject on
Alternative Medicine
. My edits on iridology were minor and were strictly about achieving the objectives of this Wikiproject. Which were namely the placement of the infobox, cleaning up the introduction, adding a section on evidence, and making a preliminary review of this article.

Furthermore, I totally resent being dragged into this mess by the comments of User:Fred Bauder. I have nothing to do with this matter. I am not a party in this arbitration. And, I want to be offically removed as having anything to do with any such arbitration process since I clearly have nothing to do with the behavior of irismeister . -- John Gohde 03:57, 31 May 2004 (UTC)[reply]

Relevant behavior on talk pages

Only the complainants can edit this area


Responses by the accused/supporters

Only the accused party and supporters can edit this area