Talk:Rachel Corrie
Do we really need three pictures in a six-paragraph article? -- Zoe
Does it really bother you that much? All 3 pics have a purpose, one shows her normally, one shows her in uniform, and one shows her just before the fascists ran her over. Susan Mason
Fascists? -- Zoe
This stupid idiot jumped in front of a moving bulldozer, and yet you blame the Israeli Jewish government as "fascists" for her self-inflicted death? That's sick, if not outright anti-Semitic. And why do we have zero photos for people murdered by Hamas, Hizbollah and Islamic Jihad terrorists? This smacks of an anti-Jewish propaganda. Seriously. RK
- LOL, anti-jewish propaganda. Susan's comments were kept strictly on the talk page. Perhaps you would like to point out to us what exactly in the article is propaganda? (BTW, I agree that 3 photos are not necessary). You are of course free to start and add pictures to articles on individuals killed by Hamas, etc. --snoyes 03:13 Mar 18, 2003 (UTC)
Bulldozing people is not acceptable behavior. The reason we do not have more photos on this site is because you spend more time accusing me of assaulting Judaism, then u spend uploading photos. RK, what I find sick is your derision of this person as a "stupid idiot". Do you have no compassion? Susan Mason
Later, as a group of people gathered, a Palestinian man was shot and killed by the IDF.
President Bush gave an ultimatum to the leadership of Iraq today. Later, I ate some pasta with grated cheese. Seriously, that sentence seems awkward and unrelated to the article. Perhaps if we could find the reason why the Palestinian man was shot, we could find a reason for it to be in the article. -- cprompt 05:53 Mar 18, 2003 (UTC)
Well they ran her over, then as people gathered to say, "What the gvdl is wrong with the Israeli military" they opened fire on the crowd. So it does seem related. Susan Mason
This article doesn't make sense, in one paragraph she's run over through being sucked off the top of a pile of rubble. In the next paragraph she has sand poured on her and is then run over. Also, could you cite a reference for her shouting 'my back is broken'? I've done some searching and can find nothing about it. I find it quite hard to believe that from beneath a pile of sand and over the noise of a bulldozer she could be heard shouting.
I think there's a reason that, for example, the BBC don't go into the details of her death [1], namely that seperating truth from propaganda hasn't yet been possible. There isn't any concensus amongst news sites as to how she exactly died so I don't think that if we're supposed to be presenting fact that we should yet have details of how she died. -- Ams80 12:16 Mar 18, 2003 (UTC)