Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Problems with loop quantum gravity
This is an attempt to circumvent Wikipedia policy on cooperative editing. 12:20, 2004 Nov 29 User:Lumidek created this article as a copy of an old version of Objections to the theory of loop quantum gravity. The reason given, was his disgust about other users editing "his" article and "his" article being flagged with dispute and attention tags. Of course even the original creation of Objections to the theory of loop quantum gravity was against Wikipedia policy against separate articles per POV. But given that the Loop quantum gravity article was rather long at that time, the majority of contributors seem to favor a separate "Criticism" article. --Pjacobi 19:26, 2004 Dec 28 (UTC)
- Delete, use Wikipedia:Dispute resolution, which does not include forking off your own version of an article. --fvw* 19:43, 2004 Dec 28 (UTC)
- Delete and FORCE unification into Objections to the theory of loop quantum gravity. The whole Loop quantum gravity-related edit war problems go much further: NPOV dispute arbitration and general cleanup/copy editing of all three articles Loop quantum gravity, Objections to the theory of loop quantum gravity and Problems with loop quantum gravity is direly needed. All are full of POV affirmations and display very dubious structure/layout. Someone other than the usual editors should look into this. Phils 19:47, 28 Dec 2004 (UTC)
- Delete and merge. -Lethe | Talk 20:15, Dec 28, 2004 (UTC)