Murder of Carmen Gayheart
Carmen Gayheart | |
|---|---|
| Born | Carmen Gabriella Tortora September 2, 1970 Fort Lauderdale, Florida, U.S. |
| Died | April 27, 1994 (aged 23) Hamilton County, Florida, U.S. |
| Cause of death | Strangulation, Gunshot Wound |
| Resting place | Forest Lawn Memorial Gardens Lake City, Florida, US |
| Education | Lake City Community College |
| Known for | Victim of a kidnapping, rape, and murder case |
On April 27, 1994, 23-year-old Carmen Gayheart (September 2, 1970 – April 27, 1994), a nursing student and mother of two, was abducted in Lake City, Florida, United States, and subsequently raped and murdered in Hamilton County, Florida. Gayheart was enrolled at Lake City Community College at the time of her death.
The perpetrators, Anthony Floyd Wainwright (October 22, 1970 – June 10, 2025)[1] and Richard Eugene Hamilton (February 16, 1963 – January 13, 2023),[2] had escaped from a North Carolina prison just days prior to the crime. Following a multi-state investigation, both men were apprehended, tried, and convicted of first-degree murder. Both were sentenced to death.
Hamilton remained on Florida's death row until his death from natural causes on January 13, 2023. Wainwright, the surviving co-defendant, was executed on June 10, 2025.[3][4]
Murder
[edit]On April 27, 1994, 23-year-old Carmen Gayheart, a nursing student and mother of two, was reported missing after she failed to pick up her children from daycare. Gayheart had been attending nursing classes at Lake City Community College in Lake City, Florida, and was last seen in a nearby parking lot earlier that day. When she did not arrive to collect her children as expected, her absence raised immediate concern. After an initial search by her husband, father, and classmates proved unsuccessful, she was officially reported missing.[5] Unbeknownst to her family and investigators at the time, Carmen Gayheart had been abducted at gunpoint by Anthony Wainwright and Richard Hamilton while loading groceries into the Ford Bronco she was driving in the parking lot of a Winn-Dixie supermarket.[6]
Just two days prior to kidnapping Gayheart, both Hamilton and Wainwright escaped from the Carteret Correctional Center, a minimum-security prison in Newport, North Carolina, where Wainwright was serving ten years' jail for burglary while Hamilton himself was serving 25 years for armed robbery.[7][8] The pair additionally stole a vehicle and burglarized a home, where they took two rifles before they fled to Florida, where they eventually abducted and later killed Gayheart.[9]
After abducting Carmen Gayheart, Anthony Wainwright and Richard Hamilton abandoned their original getaway vehicle at a lumber yard on U.S. 41 and fled the scene in Gayheart’s Ford Bronco with her held hostage. The men drove her to a remote wooded area behind the Fuel City Truck Stop off State Route 6 in neighboring Hamilton County, Florida. There, in an isolated location far from public view, the two men subjected Gayheart to a brutal sexual assault. According to Hamilton, following the assault, Wainwright strangled her in an apparent attempt to kill her. To ensure her death, he then shot her twice in the head with a bolt-action .22 rifle, fatally wounding the 23-year-old nursing student and mother of two. Her body was left at the scene, and the perpetrators continued their attempt to evade law enforcement.[10][6][11] During the trial, both men confessed that the other man was to blame for strangling and shooting Gayheart.
The day after Gayheart's murder, on April 28, 1994, Wainwright and Hamilton were located near Brookhaven, Mississippi. When confronted by a Mississippi State Trooper, the two fugitives engaged in a gunfight with the trooper. The result ended in Hamilton being shot in the face and Wainwright sustaining a gunshot wound, both of which were non-fatal. During their arrest, authorities recovered Gayheart’s Ford Bronco, which the suspects had been driving since fleeing the crime scene in Florida. Although the vehicle was found, there was still no sign of Gayheart herself at that time.[12][13]
Following his arrest, Hamilton waived extradition and was promptly returned to Columbia County, Florida. There, investigators with the Columbia County Sheriff’s Office conducted an in-depth interrogation regarding the disappearance of Carmen Gayheart. During the interview, Hamilton provided a detailed confession and cooperated with authorities by drawing a map of the remote site where Gayheart had been taken, raped, strangled, and ultimately shot. Though he had drawn the map, he could not identify the city or county where the area was located. Hamilton also claimed that while both he and Anthony Wainwright participated in the sexual assault, it was Wainwright who carried out the murder by shooting Gayheart.
On May 2, 1994, Tina Wheeler, a dispatcher with the Hamilton County Sheriff's Office, advised that she had recognized the map Hamilton drew as an area near State Route 6. Deputy Sheriff Mel Black and Albert Jones drove to the area at approximately 4:30 a.m. in an attempt to locate Gayheart's body. During the search, Jones noted a foul smell in the area and alerted investigators. At sunrise, approximately 7 a.m., the decomposed remains of Gayheart were discovered. The Hamilton County Sheriff's Office took the investigation into Gayheart's murder and sent the remains to the District 4 Medical Examiner's Office in Jacksonville.[14][15] After Gayheart’s body was transported to the medical examiner’s office, investigators conducted a follow-up search of the crime scene. At the recommendation of Dr. Margarita Arruza, the medical examiner, who noted that Gayheart’s remains were missing several teeth and the hyoid bone, investigators returned to the site. During the search, they successfully recovered some of her missing teeth and the hyoid bone.
Trial proceedings
[edit]Anthony Floyd Wainwright | |
|---|---|
 Mug shot of Wainwright | |
| Born | October 22, 1970 Greenville, North Carolina, U.S. |
| Died | June 10, 2025 (aged 54) |
| Cause of death | Execution by lethal injection |
| Convictions | North Carolina Larceny of a motor vehicle (2 counts) Breaking and entering and Larceny Escape prison Felony breaking and entering (2 counts) Larceny (3 counts)[16] Florida First-degree murder Kidnapping Robbery Sexual battery |
| Criminal penalty | North Carolina 15 years and 10 months (Breaking and entering) Florida Death penalty, plus three consecutive life sentences |
| Details | |
| Victims | Carmen Gayheart, 23 |
| Date | April 27, 1994 |
| Country | United States |
| State | Lake City, Florida |
| Imprisoned at | Florida State Prison (death row) |
Richard Eugene Hamilton | |
|---|---|
 Mug shot of Hamilton | |
| Born | February 16, 1963 Atlantic Beach, North Carolina, U.S. |
| Died | January 13, 2023 (aged 59) |
| Cause of death | Unknown, presumed natural causes |
| Criminal status | Died on death row in 2023 |
| Convictions | North Carolina Robbery with dangerous weapon Misdemeanor breaking and entering (3 counts) Felony breaking and entering (2 counts) Larceny Misdemeanor assault (attempt to inflict serious injury) (2 counts) Forgery (2 counts)[17] Florida First-degree murder Kidnapping Robbery Sexual battery |
| Criminal penalty | North Carolina 25 years (Robbery) Florida Death penalty, plus three consecutive life sentences |
| Details | |
| Victims | Carmen Gayheart, 23 |
| Date | April 27, 1994 |
| Country | United States |
| State | Lake City, Florida |
| Imprisoned at | Union Correctional Institution (death row) |
Following their arrests, both Hamilton and Wainwright were formally charged with multiple felonies, including first-degree murder, sexual battery, robbery, and kidnapping. In July 1994, a grand jury indicted the pair on all counts. The State Attorney for the Third Judicial Circuit, Jerry Blair, announced their intention to seek the death penalty against both men, citing the heinous and premeditated nature of the crimes, as well as the aggravating factors of kidnapping, sexual assault, and the victim’s vulnerability. The case proceeded to trial amid significant public attention and outrage over the brutality of the offenses.[18] The surviving family members of Gayheart expressed that they wanted both Wainwright and Hamilton to be executed for the rape and murder of Gayheart.[19] Because of the significant media attention given to the case, as well as the court unable to produce an unbiased jury in Hamilton County, the court decided to move the trial to Clay County, where a jury was quickly seated.
During their pre-trial detention at the Clay County Jail, both Hamilton and Wainwright repeatedly expressed intentions to escape custody. Authorities received intelligence indicating that the two men were actively planning an escape attempt, which allegedly included a plot to kill a correctional officer during the course of their breakout. Due to the seriousness of these threats and the high risk they posed, jail officials placed both men in maximum-security confinement to prevent any potential escape or violence against staff.[20] Not only that, for their court appearances, stun belts were installed on both Wainwright and Hamilton to constantly activate them to keep them under control.[21][22]
The trial and sentencing of both Wainwright and Hamilton were held before separate juries in May 1995,[23][24] and on May 30, 1995, both juries found the two men guilty of kidnapping, raping and murdering Gayheart.[25] On June 1, 1995, both juries recommended that both Wainwright and Hamilton should be sentenced to death for the most serious charge of first-degree murder.[26][27] Based on court sources, the jury in Wainwright's case handed an unanimous vote for capital punishment, while the jury in Hamilton's case issued a majority vote of 10–2.[11][6]
On June 12, 1995, both Wainwright and Hamilton were formally sentenced to death via the electric chair by Circuit Judge Vernon Douglas.[28][29] Apart from the death sentences, the judge also imposed three consecutive life sentences to each of the two men for the other offenses committed against Gayheart. The judge labeled the murder of Gayheart as "pitiless and unnecessarily torturous" and also "wicked, evil and vile."[30][31]
Appellate process
[edit]Hamilton
[edit]On October 23, 1997, Hamilton's direct appeal against his death sentence and murder conviction was dismissed by the Florida Supreme Court.[11][32][33]
On June 3, 2004, Hamilton's second appeal was rejected by the Florida Supreme Court.[34]
On March 3, 2017, the Florida Supreme Court rejected Hamilton's petition for writ of habeas corpus.[35]
On February 8, 2018, the Florida Supreme Court denied Hamilton's post-conviction appeal and affirmed his death sentence.[36]
Wainwright
[edit]On November 13, 1997, the Florida Supreme Court dismissed Wainwright's direct appeal.[6]
On November 24, 2004, a second appeal from Wainwright was turned down by the Florida Supreme Court.[37][38][39] Wainwright was one of the four death row inmates (also including Loran Kenstley Cole) to lose their appeals to the Florida Supreme Court on the same date itself.[40]
On November 13, 2007, Wainwright's appeal was rejected by the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.[41]
On November 26, 2008, Wainwright's third appeal to the Florida Supreme Court was denied.[42]
In July 2023, the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals dismissed Wainwright's appeal, and also rejected Wainwright's submission of new DNA evidence on the basis that they were insufficient to rebut the findings of the trial DNA experts and demonstrate his alleged innocence.[43][44]
On April 15, 2024, the U.S. Supreme Court dismissed Wainwright's final appeal against his death sentence.[45]
Hamilton's death
[edit]On January 13, 2023, Hamilton died at the age of 59 while incarcerated at Union Correctional Institution in Florida, after spending approximately 28 years on death row. The Florida Department of Corrections did not publicly disclose the cause of his death.[46]
Execution of Wainwright
[edit]On May 10, 2025, Florida governor Ron DeSantis signed a death warrant for Anthony Wainwright, scheduling his execution date as June 10, 2025.[47][48]
Wainwright was scheduled to have an evidentiary hearing at the Hamilton County Courthouse in Jasper on May 19; however, Judge Melissa Olin declined to proceed with the hearing on May 16, citing lack of evidence to proceed with an evidentiary hearing.[49] Following the ruling, Wainwright's attorneys filed an appeal to the Florida Supreme Court on May 20, with a motion for a stay of execution filed with the court on May 23. The court denied the request on June 3.[50][51]
On June 6, Wainwright appealed to the U.S Supreme Court to halt his impending execution, citing prenatal exposure to Agent Orange, but the appeal was rejected.[52][53]
Wainwright’s execution was the sixth scheduled in Florida in 2025. On May 15, 2025, serial killer Glen Edward Rogers was executed by lethal injection, just five days after the approval of Wainwright's death warrant.[54][55] Simultaneously, an Alabama death row inmate named Gregory Hunt, who was found guilty of the 1988 rape and murder of Karen Lane, was scheduled to be executed by nitrogen hypoxia on the same date as Wainwright.[56] Wainwright was one of four inmates scheduled to be executed across four different states in the U.S. over a four-day period between June 10 and June 13, 2025.[57]
On June 10, 2025, Wainwright was put to death by lethal injection in the Florida State Prison. The official time of death was 6:22 pm EDT. He made no final statement.[58] His execution took place less than an hour earlier than Hunt, who was put to death by nitrogen hypoxia in Alabama and pronounced dead at 6:26 pm CDT.[59]
Aftermath
[edit]In the aftermath of her murder, Carmen Gayheart's funeral was scheduled to be held on May 10, 1994.[60] A trust fund was also set up for her two children.[61]
In May 2014, about 20 years after the rape and murder of Gayheart, her sister expressed in an interview that she and her mother were still waiting for justice to be served and hoped to see both Hamilton and Wainwright executed for murdering her sister, whom she described as the "sweetest girl on the face of the earth". It was further revealed that Gayheart's father had since died in 2013, and Gayheart's sister even petitioned to the governor to sign death warrants for both Hamilton and Wainwright to ensure their executions be conducted sooner.[62] Gayheart's mother also died in 2022 from cancer.
Mississippi Trooper John Wayne Leggett, the police officer who first spotted the two killers and engaged in a gunfight with them, recounted the case in 2018. Leggett stated that despite not initially realizing that the duo were fugitives, he nonetheless followed them after seeing them in an out-of-state vehicle and suspecting them, and his actions thus contributed to the arrests of both Wainwright and Hamilton. Leggett stated that this was the most unforgettable experience he had throughout the 27 years of his law enforcement career. It was further reported that for his role in apprehending the suspects, Leggett was honored as the statewide "Trooper of the Year" and received the Highway Patrol's Medal of Valor. He was also recognized by Congress and named a 1994 "Top Cop" by the National Association of Police Organizations.[63]
See also
[edit]- Capital punishment in Florida
- List of people executed in Florida
- List of people executed in the United States in 2025
References
[edit]- ^ "Corrections Offender Network – WAINWRIGHT, ANTHONY F". Florida Department of Corrections. Retrieved May 12, 2025.
- ^ "Corrections Offender Network – HAMILTON, RICHARD E". Florida Department of Corrections. Retrieved May 12, 2025.
- ^ "North Carolina man convicted of 1994 rape, murder of Florida woman to be executed". The Florida Times Union. May 12, 2025.
- ^ "Florida executes man convicted of raping, killing woman 3 decades ago". Tampa Bay Times. June 10, 2025.
- ^ "Two escaped prisoners from North Carolina were caught with the woman's car in Mississippi". Sarasota Herald-Tribune. April 30, 1994.
- ^ a b c d Wainwright v. State [1997], Florida Supreme Court (United States).
- ^ "Four death row inmates lost their appeals". Sarasota Herald-Tribune. November 25, 2004.
- ^ "Justices say BB gun can be deadly". Sarasota Herald-Tribune. October 24, 1997.
- ^ "Florida death warrant signed for man guilty of 1994 rape and murder in Hamilton County". WUSF. May 12, 2025.
- ^ "Four on death row lose appeals". Lakeland Ledger. November 25, 2004.
- ^ a b c Hamilton v. State [1997], Florida Supreme Court (United States).
- ^ "Woman still missing after car recovered". Lakeland Ledger. April 30, 1994.
- ^ "N.C. escapees has woman's car". Star-News. April 30, 1994.
- ^ "Deputies find body of missing student". Lakeland Ledger. May 3, 1994.
- ^ "Body of missing Lake City woman found". UPI. May 2, 1994.
- ^ "Offender Public Information - Anthony F Wainwright". North Carolina Department of Adult Correction.
- ^ "Offender Public Information - Richard E Hamilton". North Carolina Department of Adult Correction.
- ^ "2 indicted in Gayheart's murder". Gainesville Sun. July 16, 1994.
- ^ "Victim's family wants suspects put to death". Gainesville Sun. July 16, 1994.
- ^ "Defendants in Gayheart trial vow they'll break out of jail". Gainesville Sun. May 23, 1995.
- ^ "Defendants To Wear Shock Belts At Trial". Gainesville Sun. April 4, 1995.
- ^ "Shock: Stun devices labeled by some as inhumane". Gainesville Sun. June 21, 1999.
- ^ "Two juries will hear Gayheart rape and murder". Gainesville Sun. March 14, 1995.
- ^ "Jury selection continues". Gainesville Sun. May 17, 1995.
- ^ "Both suspects guilty". Gainesville Sun. May 31, 1995.
- ^ "Execute Gayheart's killers, juries say". Gainesville Sun. June 2, 1995.
- ^ "Separate juries call for death penalty of 2". Lakeland Ledger. June 6, 1995.
- ^ "Escapees Sentenced To Die For Murder". Lakeland Ledger. June 13, 1995.
- ^ "Florida Nc Men Get Death Sentences". Star-News. June 13, 1995.
- ^ "Gayheart Killers Get Death". Gainesville Sun. June 13, 1995.
- ^ "Prison Escapees Sentenced To Die In Electric Chair For 1994 rape, murder". Ocala Star-Banner. June 13, 1995.
- ^ "Ruling: Bb Guns Can Be Deadly". Boca Raton News. October 24, 1997.
- ^ "Court rules BB gun deadly". Star-News. October 24, 1997.
- ^ Hamilton v. State [2004], Florida Supreme Court (United States).
- ^ Hamilton v. Jones [2017], Florida Supreme Court (United States).
- ^ Hamilton v. State [2018], Florida Supreme Court (United States).
- ^ "Four Death Row appeals rejected". Gainesville Sun. November 25, 2004.
- ^ "Killer captured in Lake loses appeal". Ocala Star-Banner. November 25, 2004.
- ^ Wainwright v. State [2004], Florida Supreme Court (United States).
- ^ "Four death row inmates lose appeals before state high court". Tampa Bay Times. November 25, 2004.
- ^ Wainwright v. State [2007], 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals (United States).
- ^ Wainwright v. State [2008], Florida Supreme Court (United States).
- ^ "Death row inmate appeal denied in 1994 kidnapping, murder in Lake City". WCJB. July 20, 2023.
- ^ Wainwright v. Secretary [2023], 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals (United States).
- ^ Wainwright v. Dixon [2024], U.S. Supreme Court (United States).
- ^ "Convicted murderer dies on death row". Lake City Reporter. January 31, 2023.
- ^ "DeSantis signs death warrant for man convicted in 1994 kidnapping, murder". Tampa Bay Times. May 10, 2025.
- ^ "DeSantis signs execution order for man who killed Florida woman abducted from Winn-Dixie parking lot in 1994". CBS News. May 10, 2025.
- ^ Futch, Jason (May 21, 2025). "Judge Olin Rejects Hearing as Wainwright Execution Nears" (PDF). Riverbend News. pp. 1, 3. Retrieved May 21, 2025.
- ^ "Anthony Floyd Wainwright v. State of Florida". acis.flcourts.gov. Retrieved 2025-05-26.
- ^ "Florida Supreme Court denies request to stay execution of man convicted of 1994 Hamilton County murder". WCTV. June 3, 2025. Retrieved June 6, 2025.
- ^ "Agent Orange argued in bid to halt execution". Lake City Reporter. June 6, 2025.
- ^ "Supreme Court Paves Way For Florida Execution Today Of Anthony Wainwright". Tampa Free Press. June 10, 2025.
- ^ "2 more executions set in Florida, making it 6 so far in 2025". Associated Press. May 13, 2025.
- ^ "Serial killer addresses Donald Trump in last words before execution in Florida". The Straits Times. 15 May 2025.
- ^ "A look at the status of US executions in 2025". Associated Press. May 15, 2025.
- ^ "4 executions are scheduled in 4 states over four days this week. Here's what we know". CNN. June 10, 2025.
- ^ "Florida executes man convicted of raping and killing a woman 3 decades ago". Associated Press. June 10, 2025.
- ^ "Alabama executes a man by nitrogen gas for the beating death of a woman in 1988". Associated Press. June 10, 2025.
- ^ "Slain mom's burial set". Ocala Star-Banner. May 4, 1994.
- ^ "Fund started for Gayheart's two children". Gainesville Sun. May 4, 1994.
- ^ "Grief-stricken family still waiting for daughter's killers to be executed 20 years later". WPBF. May 13, 2014.
- ^ "An April afternoon in 1994". Daily Leader. April 3, 2018.