Holocaust humor

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Arthur Szyk, "We're Running Short of Jews", 1943

There are several major aspects of humor related to the Holocaust: humor of the Jews in Nazi Germany and in Nazi concentration and extermination camps, a specific kind of "gallows humor"; German humor on the subject during the Nazi era; the appropriateness of this kind of off-color humor in modern times; modern anti-Semitic sick humor.

Aspects of Holocaust humor[edit]

The 2011 book Dead Funny by Rudolph Herzog[1] explores, among other things, the first two aspects: the humor of the oppressed and the humor of the oppressors.[2][3] One of Herzog's points is that the German humor of the era reveals the extent to which ordinary German citizens were aware of the atrocities of the regime.[3]

Chaya Ostrower [he], a pioneer in Holocaust humor research, maintained that humor was a defense mechanism that helped to endure the atrocities of the Holocaust.[4] She wrote that until recently the question of humor in concentration camps was little known to general public and had little attention in scientific community. Among many reasons for this was the common belief that the discussion of humor in the Holocaust may be seen as diminishing the Holocaust, hurting the feelings of the inmates, and trivializing the issue of extermination - if it was possible to laugh, then it was not so terrible after all. Another reason is the reluctance of the survivors to recall harsh memories associated with the unnatural circumstances that evoked humor. Also, the scholars treated humor to be only of second importance in the life of Holocaust survivors. In 2009 Yad Vashem published a book in Hebrew "Without humor we would have committed suicide". In 2014 it was published also in English "It kept us alive: humor as a defense mechanism in the Holocaust". In this book you can find interviews with 55 Holocaust survivors, carried out by Dr. Ostrower where the main question was "Can you describe or tell us about humor in the Holocaust?"[5]

Terrence Des Pres, Sander Gilman, and Sidra DeKoven Ezrahi were among the first scholars to consider the appropriateness of humor about the Holocaust and who has the right to tell Holocaust jokes.[3]

Considering the cruelty of the jokes about the Holocaust, one has to distinguish the "gallows humor", i.e., the humor of the victims, from "sick humor" of the oppressors or haters of the particular social group.[6] The "gallows humor" is a coping mechanism,[7] while "sick humor" is an instrument of aggression.[6]

Holocaust humor of Nazi ghettos and camps[edit]

Viktor Frankl, a psychiatrist and a Holocaust survivor of the Auschwitz concentration camp in his 1946 book Man's Search for Meaning wrote: "To discover that there was any semblance of art in a concentration camp must be surprise enough for an outsider, but he may be even more astonished to hear that one could find a sense of humor there as well; of course, only the faint trace of one, and then only for a few seconds or minutes. Humor was another of the soul's weapons in the fight for self-preservation"... "The attempt to develop a sense of humor and to see things in a humorous light is some kind of a trick learned while mastering the art of living." Frankl further gives an example of humor in dreary circumstances. They were being transported to another camp and the train was approaching the bridge across the Danube. Over the river was the Mauthausen death camp. "Those who have never seen anything similar cannot possibly imagine the dance of joy performed in the carriage by the prisoners when they saw that our transport was not crossing the bridge and was instead heading only for Dachau." When the inmates learned that there was no crematorium in the camp, they "laughed and cracked jokes in spite of, and during, all <they> had to go through."[8] "An abnormal response to an abnormal situation is in the nature of normal behavior".[9]

Chaya Ostrower recognized three major categories of jokes in the book of interviews, Without Humor We Would Have Committed Suicide:[10] self-humor, black humor, and humor about food. She noticed that food jokes were unique for the Holocaust period.[5]

Self-humour: One of the interviewees in Without Humor... was telling about their hair being cut upon arrival to Auschwitz. Many women were crying, but she started laughing. When asked why, she answered that never in her life had she had a hairdo for free.[5]

Black humor was a means of reducing anxiety of the awareness of death. An example well-known in Warsaw: "Moishe, why are you using soap with so much fragrance?" - "When they turn me into soap, at least I will smell good".[5] Jokes about soap were in response to rumors which started circulating in 1942 about soap produced from the fat of the Jews. Other jokes of this kind: "See you again on the same shelf!" or "Don't eat much: the Germans will have less soap!"[11]

Humor about food constituted about 7 percent of humor discussed in the study. The interviewees mention that there was lots of humor about food, because food was a common subject, because there was always not enough of it. An interviewee recalls: there was a group which liked to discuss recipes. Suddenly one of them lost her mood and stopped talking. "What's wrong with her?" - "I think her cake has burned".[5]

The Holocaust-era archive clandestinely collected by a team led by Holocaust victim Emmanuel Ringelblum ("Ringelblum Archive") documented the everyday life in Nazi-organized Jewish ghettos, in particular, the Warsaw Ghetto. Among other things, the archive documented the humor perspective of the inhumane Jewish life. The archive includes jokes about Poles, Nazis, Hitler, Stalin, etc. A good deal of them were self-jokes about life, death, disease, hunger, and humiliation.[11]

Modern times[edit]

Telling Holocaust jokes in public is illegal in Germany.[12]

Anti-Semitism[edit]

Demonstrating that Holocaust humor is international, Dundes and Hachild cite two versions of a joke recorded in Germany and the United States in early 1980s: "How many Jews will fit a Volkswagen" – "506: six in the seats and 500 in the ashtrays".[6]

Admissibility of Holocaust humor[edit]

Adam Muller and Amy Freier note that in modern times increasingly many people are becoming comfortable joking about the Holocaust. They attribute this, among other reasons, to the fact that since the generation of Holocaust survivors had passed, and there is no more witnesses of the atrocities, who could provide emotional firsthand testimonies. Nevertheless the "Holocaust etiquette" prescribes to consider it as a unique, solemn and, to a degree, sacred event, and laughter related to the matter disrupts this convention and is viewed as bad taste. Some other people[who?] see modern Holocaust "comedy as a vehicle for coming to terms with the memory of Nazis' horrors".[13]

Public controversies[edit]

  • 2009: Despite being Jewish herself, Roseanne Barr was heavily criticized for her photo-shot of Hitler with a tray of "burnt Jew cookies" for a satirical Jewish magazine Heeb.[14][15][16]
  • 2016: Katie Waissel competed in the British reality series Celebrity Big Brother 18 in 2016. Housemate Christopher Biggins was removed after making a racist joke about the Holocaust towards Waissel, who is Jewish.[17]
  • 2020: Concerns and controversies at the 2020 Summer Olympics: On 21 July 2021, Japanese media reported that Kentarō Kobayashi, who was the director of the opening and closing ceremonies, utilized The Holocaust by Nazi Germany in a script for his comedy in 1998, and he made malicious and anti-Semitic jokes including "Let's play Jews genocide game (Let's play Holocaust)." After that Kobayashi was dismissed by the Olympic Committee.[18][19]
  • 2022: British comedian Jimmy Carr received a significant amount of backlash after saying that the Romani Holocaust was a "positive" during his Netflix comedy special, His Dark Material. Carr's remarks were widely condemned by Holocaust memorial and anti-racism charities, as well as by a number of politicians in the UK, with calls for Netflix to remove the special from its library.[20]

In film[edit]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ Rudolph Herzog, Dead Funny. Telling Jokes in Hitler's Germany, 2011
  2. ^ "The Sound of Young America: Writer and Filmmaker Rudolph Herzog" Archived 2022-03-09 at the Wayback Machine, transcript of the interview at the Bullseye with Jesse Thorn podcast
  3. ^ a b c Monica Osborne, "Springtime for Hitler", The New Republic, August 21, 2011, a review of Herzog's book
  4. ^ Humor as a Defense Mechanism during the Holocaust, Dr Chaya Ostrower Archived 2022-02-15 at the Wayback Machine; dr. Ostrower speaks about her book
    • Chaya Ostrower, ההומור כמנגנון הגנה בשואה / ha-Humor ke-mangenon haganah ba-Shoʼah [Humor as a Defense Mechanism in the Holocaust], 2000, Ph.D., Faculty of Humanities, University of Tel Aviv
  5. ^ a b c d e Chaya Ostrower [he], הומור כמנגנון הגנה בשואה Archived 2022-02-14 at the Wayback Machine ["Humor as a defense mechanism in the Holocaust"]
  6. ^ a b c Dundes, Alan, and Thomas Hauschild. “Auschwitz Jokes.” In: Humour in Society, C. Powell and G.E.C. Paton (eds., 1988, (excerpt: pp.56, 57 Archived 2022-01-14 at the Wayback Machine)
  7. ^ Chaya Ostrower [he], It Kept Us Alive: Humor in the Holocaust, 2014
  8. ^ Viktor Frankl, Man's Search for Meaning, Pocket Books, 1985, ISBN 0-671-02337-3, Part One. "Experiences in a Concentration Camp", pp.63-65 Archived 2022-03-09 at the Wayback Machine
  9. ^ Frankl, p. 3
  10. ^ Chaya Ostrower, Lelo Humor Hayeinu Mit'avdim (Without humor we would have committed suicide), Yad Vashem, 2009, a collection of interviews
  11. ^ a b Sover, Arie. 2021. Jewish Humor: An outcome of Historical Experience, Survival, and Wisdom. London: Cambridge Scholars Archived 2021-10-19 at the Wayback Machine, Section "Jewish Humor in the Holocaust", pp. 139-142 Archived 2022-02-15 at the Wayback Machine
  12. ^ Von Doron Halutz "Unkosher Nightlife and Holocaust Humor. Israelis Learn to Love the New Berlin" Archived 2022-01-14 at the Wayback Machine Spiegel International, January 21, 2011
  13. ^ ADAM MULLER, AMY FREIER, "HUMOUR, THE HOLOCAUST, AND THE TERROR OF HISTORY", AMERICANA, E-JOURNAL OF AMERICAN STUDIES IN HUNGARY, VOLUME XIII, NUMBER 1, SPRING 2017
  14. ^ Amy Zimmerman (June 23, 2017). "How Roseanne Barr Abandoned All Reason and Embraced the Alt-Right". The Daily Beast. Retrieved March 30, 2018.
  15. ^ Connor Casey (March 29, 2018). "Photos of Roseanne Barr Posing as Hitler Resurface on Social Media". popculture.com. Retrieved March 30, 2018.
  16. ^ Fox News (July 31, 2009). "Roseanne Barr Poses as Adolf Hitler in Shocking Photo Spread". Foxnews.com. Retrieved March 30, 2018.
  17. ^ "Christopher Biggins apologises for Holocaust 'joke' after being kicked off Celebrity Big Brother". The Daily Telegraph. Archived from the original on 2022-01-14. Retrieved 2022-01-14.
  18. ^ "SWC Condemns Anti-Semitic Remarks by Director of Opening Ceremony of Tokyo Olympics". Simon Wiesenthal Center. 21 July 2021. Archived from the original on 22 July 2021. Retrieved 22 July 2021.
  19. ^ Noah Oskow (21 July 2021). "Holocaust Joke Lands Olympics Opening Director in Hot Water". Unseen Japan. Archived from the original on 7 October 2021. Retrieved 22 July 2021.
  20. ^ "Jimmy Carr sparks fury with Holocaust routine in Netflix special". BBC News. BBC. 4 February 2022. Archived from the original on 4 February 2022. Retrieved 4 February 2022.
  21. ^ The Last Laugh film review Archived 2022-01-15 at the Wayback Machine, in Hebrew
  22. ^ Film review: Viano, Maurizio (1999), "Life is Beautiful: Reception, Allegory and Holocaust Laughter",
  23. ^ Alan R. Perry, "Benigni's "La vita è bella": Viktor Frankl and the Alchemy of Meaning", Italica, vol. 96, no.2, 2019, pp. 303-330, JSTOR 45281410
  24. ^ Sander L. Gilman, "Can the Shoah Be Funny? Some Thoughts on Recent and Older Films", Critical Inquiry, Vol. 26, No. 2 (Winter, 2000), pp. 279-308, JSTOR 1344124, doi:10.1086/448967
  25. ^ Millicent Marcus, "The Seriousness of Humor in Roberto Benigni's Life Is Beautiful", In: After Fellini: National Cinema in the Postmodern Age, pp. 268-284

Further reading[edit]