Jump to content

Dreams from My Real Father: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Browse history interactively
← Previous editNext edit →
Content deleted Content added
VisualWikitext
→Reception: Joel Collins
FNAS, you have no interest in this article or in any of the personages involved; you are simply following me around to be a thorn in my side with "me too" games, and, given the unsightly rash that is your user TP, you ought to stop doing that.
Line 39: Line 39:
[[David Maraniss]], author of ''[[Barack Obama: The Story]]'', called the film "preposterous", saying that it is "depressing to have so much fictional, unreported, conspiratorial, unhistorical stuff floating around." Among anti-Obama productions, Maraniss said "This DVD is the worst of the bunch."<ref name="orlando">{{cite news | last=Stratton | first=Jim | url=http://www.orlandosentinel.com/news/politics/os-obama-dvd-voters-20121018,0,5024553.story | title=Anti-Obama DVD floods local mailboxes | work=[[Orlando Sentinel]] | date=October 18, 2012 | accessdate=October 19, 2012}}</ref>
[[David Maraniss]], author of ''[[Barack Obama: The Story]]'', called the film "preposterous", saying that it is "depressing to have so much fictional, unreported, conspiratorial, unhistorical stuff floating around." Among anti-Obama productions, Maraniss said "This DVD is the worst of the bunch."<ref name="orlando">{{cite news | last=Stratton | first=Jim | url=http://www.orlandosentinel.com/news/politics/os-obama-dvd-voters-20121018,0,5024553.story | title=Anti-Obama DVD floods local mailboxes | work=[[Orlando Sentinel]] | date=October 18, 2012 | accessdate=October 19, 2012}}</ref>


At ''[[The Daily Beast]],'' commentator [[Michelle Goldberg]] wrote, "It's tempting to ignore ''Dreams from My Real Father'' because it's so preposterous... What matters here is not that a lone crank made a vulgar conspiracy video, one that outdoes even birther propaganda in its lunacy and bad taste. It’s that the video is finding an audience on the right."<ref name="daily" /> Steve Murphy, a Democratic consultant, said, "It's about the lowest thing you can do to accuse, with no evidence, the opposition candidate's mother of being a porn star... There are two motives behind this – racism and money. It's a cynical attempt to make some coin and exploit the views of the fringes of mainstream views."<ref name="thr" />
At ''[[The Daily Beast]],'' the leftist<ref>{{cite web |first= Ron |last= Radosh|authorlink= Ronald Radosh|title= Michelle Goldberg’s Jewish Problem, and Ours|url= http://pjmedia.com/ronradosh/2011/07/29/michelle-goldbergs-jewish-problem-and-ours/|work= |publisher= [[PJ Media]] |id= |pages= |page= | date=July 29, 2011 | accessdate=September 2, 2014}}</ref> commentator [[Michelle Goldberg]] wrote, "It's tempting to ignore ''Dreams from My Real Father'' because it's so preposterous... What matters here is not that a lone crank made a vulgar conspiracy video, one that outdoes even birther propaganda in its lunacy and bad taste. It’s that the video is finding an audience on the right."<ref name="daily" /> Steve Murphy, a Democratic consultant, said, "It's about the lowest thing you can do to accuse, with no evidence, the opposition candidate's mother of being a porn star... There are two motives behind this – racism and money. It's a cynical attempt to make some coin and exploit the views of the fringes of mainstream views."<ref name="thr" />


Of the ad for the film in the ''[[New York Post]]'', one ''[[Businessweek]]'' writer wrote: ''"The ad's one irrefutable claim is that the DVD is topping Amazon[.com]’s documentary sales. With few exceptions, reviewers are giving it five stars and gushing reviews. They give less credence to some of Gilbert's other films, including ''Elvis Found Alive'' and ''Paul McCartney Really Is Dead."''<ref name=bizweek>{{cite journal | journal = [[Businessweek]] | author = Julian Sancton | date = September 11, 2012 | title = 'New York Post' Runs Boldest Anti-Obama Ad Yet | url = http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2012-09-11/new-york-post-runs-boldest-anti-obama-ad-yet | accessdate = 2012-10-04 }}</ref>''
Of the ad for the film in the ''[[New York Post]]'', one ''[[Businessweek]]'' writer wrote: ''"The ad's one irrefutable claim is that the DVD is topping Amazon[.com]’s documentary sales. With few exceptions, reviewers are giving it five stars and gushing reviews. They give less credence to some of Gilbert's other films, including ''Elvis Found Alive'' and ''Paul McCartney Really Is Dead."''<ref name=bizweek>{{cite journal | journal = [[Businessweek]] | author = Julian Sancton | date = September 11, 2012 | title = 'New York Post' Runs Boldest Anti-Obama Ad Yet | url = http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2012-09-11/new-york-post-runs-boldest-anti-obama-ad-yet | accessdate = 2012-10-04 }}</ref>''

Revision as of 02:55, 19 October 2016

Dreams from My Real Father
Directed byJoel Gilbert
Written byJoel Gilbert
Produced byJoel Gilbert
Narrated byEd Law[1]
Edited byPaul Belanger
Joel Gilbert
Music byWayne Peet
Production
company
Highway 61 Entertainment
Distributed byMVD Visual
Release date
  • July 24, 2012 (2012-07-24)
Running time
95 minutes
CountryUnited States
LanguageEnglish

Dreams from My Real Father: A Story of Reds and Deception is a 2012 American documentary-style film by Joel Gilbert which claims that U.S. President Barack Obama's biological father was Communist Party USA activist Frank Marshall Davis.[2][3] The title is derived from the title of Obama's memoir Dreams from My Father.

Background

The film maintains that Frank Marshall Davis met Obama's mother Ann Dunham through her father Stanley Dunham, whom Gilbert claims was not a furniture salesman, but actually a CIA agent tasked with monitoring Communists in Hawaii.[4]

Filmmaker Joel Gilbert said the film was the result of two years of research. He claims he found nude and fetish photos of Obama's mother Ann Dunham, which he says were taken in late 1960 by Frank Marshall Davis in Davis' Hawaii home. Gilbert compared these to Dunham's high school pictures and says he found the correlation to be "obvious". The Hollywood Reporter said, "He did not use an expert, however, to support his finding."[4]

Gilbert says that over one million copies of his film were mailed to voters in Iowa, Ohio, Nevada, New Hampshire and Colorado in the time leading up to the 2012 United States presidential election. He refused to disclose who funded the film's distribution, and a report by The Daily Beast pointed out that there was no way to verify the numbers claimed by Gilbert.[3] A complaint was filed with the Federal Election Commission, but the commission determined the film was "press", and therefore was not required to disclose how it was funded.[5]

Reception

Critical reaction to the film was largely negative, with exceptions: Bill Armistead, the chairman of the Alabama Republican Party, endorsed the film and called its theory "absolutely terrifying".[6] WorldNetDaily's Jerome Corsi accepted the film's photographic claims, calling it "compelling".[7] Jack Cashill, also a WorldNetDaily contributor, called the film "the most fascinating video treatment of the Obama story that I have yet to see."[8]

Among conservatives the reaction was mixed. Some believers in the Birther theory, such as Orly Taitz, disliked the film, since it claims Obama's father was an American, albeit a Communist.[9] Gilbert, in turn, has disparaged this position: "...'birthers' are barking up the wrong tree. It's not a question of where Obama was born -- but rather, one of paternity."[10] Conservative lawyer Loren Collins considered that Gilbert's claims damaged American conservatism and made a detailed analysis of them, concluding that they were, in effect, fiction.[11]

David Maraniss, author of Barack Obama: The Story, called the film "preposterous", saying that it is "depressing to have so much fictional, unreported, conspiratorial, unhistorical stuff floating around." Among anti-Obama productions, Maraniss said "This DVD is the worst of the bunch."[2]

At The Daily Beast, the leftist[12] commentator Michelle Goldberg wrote, "It's tempting to ignore Dreams from My Real Father because it's so preposterous... What matters here is not that a lone crank made a vulgar conspiracy video, one that outdoes even birther propaganda in its lunacy and bad taste. It’s that the video is finding an audience on the right."[3] Steve Murphy, a Democratic consultant, said, "It's about the lowest thing you can do to accuse, with no evidence, the opposition candidate's mother of being a porn star... There are two motives behind this – racism and money. It's a cynical attempt to make some coin and exploit the views of the fringes of mainstream views."[4]

Of the ad for the film in the New York Post, one Businessweek writer wrote: "The ad's one irrefutable claim is that the DVD is topping Amazon[.com]’s documentary sales. With few exceptions, reviewers are giving it five stars and gushing reviews. They give less credence to some of Gilbert's other films, including Elvis Found Alive and Paul McCartney Really Is Dead."[13]

References

  1. ^ Tapson, Mark (Aug 14, 2012). "Dreams from My Real Father: A Story of Reds and Deception". frontpagemag.com. Retrieved 1 October 2012.
  2. ^ a b Stratton, Jim (October 18, 2012). "Anti-Obama DVD floods local mailboxes". Orlando Sentinel. Retrieved October 19, 2012.
  3. ^ a b c Goldberg, Michelle (September 28, 2012). "With 'Dreams from My Real Father,' Have Obama Haters Hit Rock Bottom?". The Daily Beast. Retrieved October 3, 2012.
  4. ^ a b c Staff (September 28, 2012). "New Anti-Obama Film Claims His Mother Posed for Nude Photos". The Hollywood Reporter. Retrieved October 3, 2012.
  5. ^ Weigel, David (April 8, 2016). "How a film about Obama's communist 'real father' won at the FEC". Washington Post.
  6. ^ Rayfield, Jillian (September 20, 2012). "Alabama GOP chairman goes birther". Salon. Retrieved October 3, 2012.
  7. ^ Corsi, Dr. Jerome (2012-04-25). "FILM: PRESIDENT'S FATHER NOT BARACK OBAMA – 2 years of research, rare photos support compelling case".
  8. ^ Cashill, Jack (May 15, 2012). "Now about Obama's Teenage Years!". American Thinker.
  9. ^ Reilly, Ryan J. (May 16, 2012). "Batty 'Birther' Movie Divides Conspiracy Diehards". Talking Points Memo. Retrieved 1 October 2012.
  10. ^ Carter, R.J. (June 6, 2012). "Joel Gilbert: Birthers Asking Wrong Question on Obama Parentage". The Trades. Retrieved September 2, 2014.
  11. ^ Loren Collins, "Joel Gilbert's Dreams from my Real Father"
  12. ^ Radosh, Ron (July 29, 2011). "Michelle Goldberg's Jewish Problem, and Ours". PJ Media. Retrieved September 2, 2014.
  13. ^ Julian Sancton (September 11, 2012). "'New York Post' Runs Boldest Anti-Obama Ad Yet". Businessweek. Retrieved 2012-10-04.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Dreams_from_My_Real_Father&oldid=745065197"